At a recent Yale University discussion, writers Ayad Akhtar, Daniel Kehlmann, and Meghan O’Rourke joined journalist James Surowiecki to explore how AI is reshaping language, creativity, and human thought.
AI Is Changing How We Think
The panelists described their relationship with AI as both fascinating and unsettling. Kehlmann called it “extremely helpful and utterly amazing” while also acknowledging its risks. O’Rourke said AI can feel surprisingly persuasive because people naturally project human qualities onto language written in the first person.
Akhtar argued that AI exposes broader trends that have been shaping society for years, including algorithm-driven choices and automated forms of cognition.
What AI Reveals About Humans
Kehlmann suggested that large language models force us to rethink intelligence itself. Referencing Geoffrey Hinton’s famous observation, he noted that human language generation may be less mysterious than many assume.
At the same time, all three writers stressed an important distinction: AI operates through context, while humans operate through lived experience. Akhtar described this gap as the key difference between machines and people.
The Future of Writing
The panelists agreed that AI will transform creative industries and the labor market. O’Rourke warned that AI could threaten deep attention and meaningful engagement with language, while also offering benefits in research and accessibility.
Despite concerns, the writers remained optimistic about human-made art. As Kehlmann put it, people are drawn to art because a human being is speaking to them, something AI still cannot replicate.
